Allensandra, 22: A Person of “Both”
“I have realized that my lack of space to fit is actually a space of my own making.”
My story is shaped by my parents’ migration and my own move after that. Being the child of migrants gives you a sense of elsewhere, but moving yourself makes you realise that belonging is not something you can easily feel. It is a complicated and often painful search that you won’t be able to easily find.
My sister and I grew up with our grandparents in Kerala, India. It was a simple life: a small house, a big garden and a quiet surrounding. My dad left for a visit to Germany shortly after I was born in 2005. Back then, my mom was working as an accountant for a pharmaceutical company, but their lives changed quickly when my dad decided to move and eventually settle in Italy. My mom joined him there a few years later, right after my sister was born. For years, our parents were mostly just voices on the phone or faces we saw a few times in a year. We spent so much time calculating the days until their next one-month visit. As my grandparents got older, they realized they couldn’t keep up with two growing girls anymore. So, it was decided that we would join our parents in Italy. I was eleven, fueled by a simple, childlike joy: I finally got to be with my mom and dad.
When I first came to Italy, I remember being amazed by the different buildings, language, and people. But things slowly became serious. We arrived to a life of survival. My father worked as a caretaker for an elderly man; my mother was a babysitter. My dad wanted us to integrate quickly so he became strict with our language learning. It was “If you want to say anything, say it in Italian,” no more Malayalam spoken at home.
Middle school was where the fracture in my identity truly began. I was placed into a public school without knowing the language, a stranger in a room full of students who had never seen an “immigrant classmate.” Aside from the lessons I learned, what I remember the most is the feeling of isolation. I would cry as they made fun of me, excluded me from games, and signaled in a thousand small ways that I was different. My teachers were kind, but this period deeply affected my sense of self. I became shy, introverted, and had a continuous habit of questioning myself. Am I saying this right? Do I look right? Am I too much? Even after I learned the language, the emotional scars remained. Being different wasn’t the only thing that made that period difficult; other things included financial difficulties, the fact that my parents weren’t as familiar with the system, and in some way, my own reluctance to express my desires and ask for some treats.
High school was not as traumatic as middle school, but the lessons felt like robotic marathons, somehow I could not bring myself to enjoy it, so I made the choice to return back to India to finish high school. At first, I was shy, withdrawn, and unsure. But slowly, something opened. People approached me, spoke with me, and included me. I began to feel like myself again. I studied well, participated in activities, danced again, something I had loved since childhood. I felt the comfort of the rain, the familiarity of the tea, and the ease of slowly taking up space.
My return to Italy for university was driven by my mother’s fears. In the backdrop of our lives, there was the constant hum of gendered expectations and safety concerns. My mother, seeing the news of violence against women in India, wanted me near herself. Her own life had been shaped by the sacrifices migrant women make, staying in a difficult marriage because culture and religion offer no “respectable way out”; as such, she protects us in her own way.
And now, I can never truly stay in one place anymore. When I am in India, I crave the order, the pasta, and the specific rhythm of Italian life. When I am in Italy, I ache for dosa and the heat of the Indian sun. I have become a person of “both.”
Today, Italian is my daily language. It is the language I use to navigate my studies and my work. Italy has shaped my worldview, providing me with a safe environment to grow. I can cook a perfect carbonara (no cream, of course) as easily as I can prepare tonno e sugo. These are my comfort foods.
Yet, I am aware that in the eyes of many Italians, I will always be the other. I am questioned, I am seen as different, and I still encounter the sharp edges of a society that struggles to see me as one of its own. I have realized that my lack of space to fit is actually a space of my own making.

Leave a Reply